Phantom Stock and Stock Appreciation Rights tax

Phantom stock and stock appreciation rights pay cash tied to share value, but you never own a share. That means no capital-gains rate ever, the whole payout is ordinary income at settlement, plus payroll tax, exactly like a bonus.

Calculator

Put your own numbers in. Nothing is stored or sent anywhere, it runs in your browser.

Phantom payout details

Updated for 2026 rules

Payout amount

Cash settled at vesting or a liquidity event.

Your other ordinary income

How are you paid?

Filing status

Tax on the phantom payout

Enter the payout and press Calculate to see the tax on it.

One taxable event, and it is never capital gain Phantom stock and stock appreciation rights are contract promises to pay cash tied to share value, you never own a share, so there is no basis, no holding period, and no capital-gains rate. The entire payout is ordinary income at settlement, exactly like a cash bonus, with payroll tax on top.

Why the whole payout is ordinary income

Ordinary income when paid or settled: no LTCG treatment. Common in S corps (which cannot have two stock classes) and LLCs. Tax treatment mirrors a cash bonus. Because it settles in cash, an employee pays FICA and a contractor pays self-employment tax, reported on W-2 for an employee, 1099-NEC for a contractor.

On a $25,000 payout for an employee already earning $150,000: the payout adds $6,000 in federal income tax and $1,913 in FICA, leaving $17,088 after its own tax. A real RSU of the same value would be taxed the same way at vesting, the difference is only that a share, once held, can later earn capital-gains treatment. Phantom stock never can.

Compare the instruments

The other equity instruments

RSU tax The equity mistake that costs the most: under-withholding at vest. ISO tax The equity mistake that costs the most: AMT on an exercise you never sold. NSO tax The equity mistake that costs the most: tax due on exercise with no cash to pay it. ESPP tax The equity mistake that costs the most: selling one day too early. QSBS tax The equity mistake that costs the most: assuming five years when the rules just changed.

Equity is two taxable events, not one

Vesting or exercising is ordinary income; selling later is a capital gain or loss. The costliest equity mistakes come from treating that two-layer structure as one: underestimating the vesting-day bill, or missing a holding period that would have turned ordinary income into a lower capital-gains rate. Work out both layers before the vest, not at filing.

Model the sale side

What this covers

Federal treatment for the 2026 tax year, from the verified dataset.
Single filer taking the standard deduction in the worked figures.
Equity income stacks on top of salary, so it fills your highest brackets, the figures reflect that rather than taxing it in isolation.
Informational only, not tax advice. Equity decisions are worth a professional's time.